_____________________________
                                                |                             
                       _Benjamin BETHEL Sr._____|
                      | (1782 - 1873)           |
                      |                         |_____________________________
                      |                                                       
 _Benjamin BETHEL Jr._|
| (1815 - 1873) m 1853|
|                     |                          _William CARRAWAY ___________
|                     |                         | (1754 - 1834) m 1785        
|                     |_Charity CARRAWAY _______|
|                       (1785 - 1845)           |
|                                               |_Elizabeth LNU ______________
|                                                 (1764 - 1838) m 1785        
|
|--M. M. BETHEL 
|  (1859 - ....)
|                                                _Thomas COBBS _______________+
|                                               | (1764 - 1816) m 1790        
|                      _William Anderson COBB __|
|                     | (1798 - 1877) m 1819    |
|                     |                         |_Catherine STITH ____________
|                     |                           (1766 - 1832) m 1790        
|_Mary Keziah COBB ___|
  (1833 - 1880) m 1853|
                      |                          _Daniel Downie MACMURPHY Sr._+
                      |                         | (1737 - 1819) m 1778        
                      |_Jane Augusta MACMURPHY _|
                        (1797 - 1854) m 1819    |
                                                |_Susannah CROSSLEY __________+
                                                  (1750 - 1818) m 1778