___________________________ | _Samuel BUTLER ___________| | (1785 - 1851) | | |___________________________ | _Courtland Philip BUTLER _| | (1813 - 1891) | | | _Gilbert James LIVINGSTON _+ | | | (1758 - 1833) | |_Judith Lewis LIVINGSTON _| | (1785 - 1858) | | |_Susannah LEWIS ___________ | (1761 - 1822) | |--Mary Elizabeth BUTLER | (1850 - 1897) | ___________________________ | | | __________________________| | | | | | |___________________________ | | |_Elizabeth Slade PIERCE __| (1822 - 1901) | | ___________________________ | | |__________________________| | |___________________________