_____________________ | ___________________________| | | | |_____________________ | _Samuel BUTLER ___________| | (1785 - 1851) | | | _____________________ | | | | |___________________________| | | | |_____________________ | | |--Courtland Philip BUTLER | (1813 - 1891) | _James LIVINGSTON ___+ | | (1728 - 1790) | _Gilbert James LIVINGSTON _| | | (1758 - 1833) | | | |_Judith NEWCOMB _____ | | (1733 - 1808) |_Judith Lewis LIVINGSTON _| (1785 - 1858) | | _____________________ | | |_Susannah LEWIS ___________| (1761 - 1822) | |_____________________