___________________________
                                                      |                           
                            _Samuel BUTLER ___________|
                           | (1785 - 1851)            |
                           |                          |___________________________
                           |                                                      
 _Courtland Philip BUTLER _|
| (1813 - 1891)            |
|                          |                           _Gilbert James LIVINGSTON _+
|                          |                          | (1758 - 1833)             
|                          |_Judith Lewis LIVINGSTON _|
|                            (1785 - 1858)            |
|                                                     |_Susannah LEWIS ___________
|                                                       (1761 - 1822)             
|
|--Mary Elizabeth BUTLER 
|  (1850 - 1897)
|                                                      ___________________________
|                                                     |                           
|                           __________________________|
|                          |                          |
|                          |                          |___________________________
|                          |                                                      
|_Elizabeth Slade PIERCE __|
  (1822 - 1901)            |
                           |                           ___________________________
                           |                          |                           
                           |__________________________|
                                                      |
                                                      |___________________________