_Benjamin BETHEL Sr._____
                                               | (1782 - 1873)           
                          _Benjamin BETHEL Jr._|
                         | (1815 - 1873) m 1853|
                         |                     |_Charity CARRAWAY _______+
                         |                       (1785 - 1845)           
 _Charles Edward BETHEL _|
| (1862 - ....) m 1880   |
|                        |                      _William Anderson COBB __+
|                        |                     | (1798 - 1877) m 1819    
|                        |_Mary Keziah COBB ___|
|                          (1833 - 1880) m 1853|
|                                              |_Jane Augusta MACMURPHY _+
|                                                (1797 - 1854) m 1819    
|
|--Mary Kate BETHEL 
|  
|                                               _________________________
|                                              |                         
|                         _____________________|
|                        |                     |
|                        |                     |_________________________
|                        |                                               
|_Lee SHERMAN ___________|
   m 1880                |
                         |                      _________________________
                         |                     |                         
                         |_____________________|
                                               |
                                               |_________________________