_______________________________ | _Valentine Gill HALL Sr_| | | | |_______________________________ | _Valentine Gill HALL Jr__| | (1834 - 1880) | | | _______________________________ | | | | |_Susan TONNELÉ ________| | | | |_______________________________ | | |--Mary Livingston HALL | (1869 - 1872) | _______________________________ | | | _Edward Hunter LUDLOW __| | | (1810 - 1884) m 1833 | | | |_______________________________ | | |_Mary Livingston LUDLOW _| (1843 - 1919) | | _Edward Philip LIVINGSTON _____+ | | (1779 - 1843) |_Elizabeth LIVINGSTON __| (1813 - 1896) m 1833 | |_Elizabeth Stevens LIVINGSTON _+ (1780 - 1829)